What We Recycle
Aluminum Cans
FREE
Highly recyclable and great for the environment, aluminum cans are awesome. The Exchange takes aluminum cans for free.
This includes aluminum pet food cans – please make sure the cans are aluminum, and rinsed well before you drop them off!
Learn why you should drink out of Aluminum.
Antifreeze
Used Antifreeze: $2.00/Gallon
Antifreeze contains ethylene glycol or propylene glycol, as well as other chemicals, that are highly toxic. The cool thing about antifreeze is that it can be recycled into new antifreeze with the proper filtering equipment. The same company that collects our motor oil collects our antifreeze.
Appliances
$15-small appliance, $22-large appliance, $55-refrigerators & freezers
We collect and recycle virtually every kind of appliance. Using various local contractors we transport all appliances off Orcas to be recycled as scrap metal. We pay to have them removed, and thus we charge for the service. Refrigerated appliances cost more because a trained technician must remove the components containing Freon, a chemical hazardous waste.
We use various vendors to take our appliances off island to be recycled. Like all of our recycling programs we do this at or near cost because it’s the right thing to do!
Batteries
Vehicle batteries: Free; All other: $2/pound
At The Exchange we have been recycling all types of batteries for a decade. But it’s getting both more important, and will soon be required by law.
More important for safety reasons: the proliferation of lithium-ion batteries has led to a growing number of garbage fires all over the Country.
As of January 2027, all batteries must be recycled as per Washington State Law (RCW 70A.555). This is a great law, and like our electronics and paint recycling programs it will be free to drop off your batteries.
San Juan County is also considering a recycling mandate that would start before the state-wide law takes effect. At The Exchange we are asking that everyone recycle all their batteries by dropping them off at the scale house.
Learn more about the different types of batteries.
Cardboard
FREE!
We accept clean, dry, flat corrugated cardboard for free!
No wax coating, styrofoam, bubble wrap, or other packing materials.
Learn how to properly recycle cardboard.
Cartons
Cartons go in the co-mingled recycling.
Tetra Pak packages, rectangular cartons that hold soups and soup stock, and milk, juice and wine cartons. All these types of cartons go into comingled recycling.
Learn why type of packaging is one of the biggest scams in the recycling world.
Co-Mingled
$9/can, $400/ton
We DO NOT accept recyclables that are in BLACK OR WHITE PLASTIC BAGS. In fact, avoid the use of plastic bags completely! Collect your clean recyclables in brown paper shopping bags, or cardboard boxes.
San Juan County shifted away from sorting recyclables a decade ago, as the industry shifted to co-mingled recycling, where you just throw everything (paper, plastic, steel, aluminum, glass) into one can. This reflected the move towards better and better “MRFs” or Materials Recovery Facilities - that use all kinds of high-tech machinery for sorting out all the recyclables. We currently ship our comingled recycling to a facility in Woodinville where our materials are sorted mechanically and by hand.
Here’s a complete list of what we will (and will not) accept:
Compostable
We currently only accept yard waste (green waste, branches, NO noxious weeds!). See Yard Waste for more info.
We do not take food waste yet, but are headed in that direction. San Juan County is currently exploring options to offer commercial level composting of food waste in the islands.
Until then, read up on composting:
Cooking Oil
$100/ton or $0.50/gallon
The Exchange started accepting Used Cooking Oil in the spring of 2014. We collect it from households and restaurants and it is recycled into bio-fuel by an off-island company. We plan to one day upgrade our UCO service to the point where we can refine fuel for our own vehicles on site!
Electronics
FREE
In 2014 ORS became a member of the state E-cycle program and can accept TVs, CPUs, laptops and computer monitors at no charge.
Televisions and computers contain a host of toxic substances such as lead, cadmium, mercury, and arsenic. These toxic substances can contaminate groundwater when landfilled. Separate them from your waste stream and bring them to us for proper recycling!
FYI: The State program does not cover things like printers, scanners, stereos, DVD players etc… however we will make sure they are recycled (not landfilled) for a small fee.
Learn more:
Fluorescent Tubes
$1.00 for CFLs, $2.00 for tubes
Fluorescent tubes contain mercury, a powerful toxin. They truly need to be handled safely.
While there was a State-funded recycling program for these, it ended abruptly in January 2026. Now The Exchange must charge a small fee for proper recycling. You can find out more about the defunct program here.
Glass
FREE!
We accept glass (clean, empty, caps & corks removed) for free at The Exchange. We crush it up into sand! Ask us about taking some of our Zero Waste glass-sand home for projects (see below)!
Metals
Mixed Metals: $450/ton
Currently we are charging our normal scale weight for mixed metal items. Bikes, barbecues, metal construction waste–if it has tires or plastic or anything besides metal attached to it, its value is substantially lower than pure metal. We intend to move towards a sorting system for metals, and then the prices will drop. But until we can build the infrastructure for sorting we will need to charge $450/ ton.
Separated aluminum cans and steel cans are always FREE.
Motor Oil
$2.00/Gallon
The used motor oil we collect goes to an off island refinery. They refine it an turn it into new motor oil, or “bunker fuel” which is is used in the shipping industry.
Paint
ORS is a FREE recycling center for all latex and oil-based paint and stains!!
Washington’s paint stewardship law requires the paint manufacturing industry to develop a financially sustainable and environmentally responsible program to manage post-consumer architectural paint.
The program includes education about buying the right amount of paint, tips for using up remaining paint, and setting up convenient recycling locations throughout the state.
Paint manufacturers established PaintCare, a nonprofit organization, to run paint stewardship programs in states with applicable laws. See paint items that can be dropped-off for free at ORS/The Exchange.
- Leaking, unlabeled, and empty containers will not be accepted at drop-off sites.
- Non-PaintCare items should be brought to our hazardous waste collection events.
Paper
$7/can (goes in comingled recycling)
Currently ORS accepts all forms of clean dry paper in the co-mingled recycling bins. These materials are generally separated at the recycling facility into “mixed paper” bales, which are sold back to the paper and cardboard industry for recycling into new paper products.
There are exceptions however; please do not put any of the following in the recycling bin:
- Shredded office paper
- Paper towels
- Paper plates
- Napkins
- Tissues
In the near future, when we have a baler facility up and running, we may collect paper products separately, at a discounted price, like we do with aluminum and cardboard.
Plastics
$7/can (goes in comingled recycling)
We currently accept #1, #2 and #5 plastics in your comingled recycling.
Plastics is the most complicated item we deal with. Everywhere is different on what they take. Learn more about plastics (which for the most part are not recyclable, or are barely recyclable).
Propane Canisters
$8 / 5-gallon canister
- 5-gallon propane canisters can be recycled at The Exchange if they are COMPLETELY EMPTY, for a fee of $8.00. Keep in mind that many businesses that sell propane have swap programs where you can get a discount on a new canister if you trade in your old one.
- More than 5-Gallons: We do not accept propane canisters over 5-gallons at The Exchange. You may be able to dispose of them at our summer Hazardous Waste Collection Event, which you can learn about here.
- Small green (Coleman) propane canisters when COMPLETELY EMPTY may be thrown into regular trash. Currently there are no recycling programs for these canisters.
Steel Cans
FREE
ORS is now accepting steel cans (aka ‘tin’ cans) for FREE. This includes soup cans, coconut water cans–and any other steel can. They almost always have ridges (see pics–ridges are a dead giveaway). If you are not sure about a can, check it with a magnet. Does it stick? Great, put it in the steel can bin.
NO OTHER METAL is allowed in these bins! Aluminum cans go in the Aluminum bins. All other metals either go in the mixed recycling, or into the large metal collection bins on the Tipping Floor. For more info, click here.
Styrofoam
Free
Tires
$12.00 with/without a rim
We store tires on site until they are collected in bulk for recycling.
Yard Waste
Green Waste: $100/ton
For a drastically reduced price, you can bring your totally green and noxious weed-free material to us (large loads of yard/forest waste, only) where it is ground up and turned into compost for use on Orcas!
To participate email info@exchangeorcas.org and request our Green Waste form.
We currently do not accept small amounts of yard and forest waste. Learn more on how to compost at home: